Bemelmans Bar

Natasha★★★★★★★★★★5.03 weeks ago

An Upper East Side classic! Went on a Thursday night and was treated to the live trio jazz band ($25 cover). Love that they have a zero proof / non alcoholic menu - the Pepito had a nice kick (tequila alternative). Still one of the great places to people watch and take in the crowd.

Joseph Flanagan★★★★★★★★★★2.05 months ago

I recently visited Bemelman’s Bar with friends. Given the high price point and the prestigious location I anticipated attentive service and high quality cocktails. The service however was mediocre and did not meet the standards usually found at a luxury hotel bar. It felt impersonal and lacked the professionalism I expected for the cost. The cocktails were such a disappointment. I ordered a gimlet from the menu and it was incredibly basic. At these prices I expect a level of craft and balance that was simply missing. It was a standard drink that could be found at almost any mid tier bar in the city. The atmosphere was also difficult to enjoy because of the noise level. It was loud enough inside that maintaining a conversation was a struggle. The space seems to have become more of a scene for a specific social crowd rather than a place for a nice drink. On a positive note the restroom was well maintained and clean. It is a small space with two stalls. I do not quite see the allure of this spot based on this visit. The lack of creative or at least well crafted drinks and the loud environment made the experience feel like a poor value overall. There are several better options nearby for someone seeking a quality martini and professional service.

Chase Fritchle★★★★★★★★★★5.05 months ago

We had the best Christmas Eve here. In fact, it will be one a tradition. The bar is very classic, old and the murals were stunning. The overall vibe makes it what it is. You’ll likely see a celebrity or two. We saw some a listers. The staff are lovely, drinks are perfect. What a place! Can’t wait to come back!

Kristjan★★★★★★★★★★5.06 months ago

Writing an aggregated review across 3 visits. Typically easy to get a table. Even if it ends up in the lounge area. I would recommend going just for cocktails. There is no value in their wine selection and food is ok. The atmosphere is obviously the draw. Great live music, and you never know who might make a guest appearance.

Wayne Cox★★★★★★★★★★5.06 months ago

Iconic nothing less nothing more!!! Found this place several years ago and my wife and I have always welcomed the nostalgia!!! Just celebrated my 60h and now based on these pics…..I have to be the oldest influencer ever!!! Serving up drinks with Johnny!!!