Scarr's Pizza

Justin Schwartz★★★★★★★★★★5.05 months ago

Get here early! We arrived a few minutes before they opened and there was already a line. The people who work here are superhuman. They move so quickly and efficiently even though there isn’t much room. It’s dazzling to watch them make pies, throw things in the oven, and cut slices. We got the vodka pesto, original, and Sicilian hotboi slices. The original was simple and just right. Good sauce-to-cheese ratio, thickness, and taste. The other slices were also amazing. No regrets, no notes. One of the best slices I’ve had in the city. Saw some reviews say that you can only sit if you order a full pie. We were able to sit at the bar with just slices, so YMMV.

Sebastian Ortega★★★★★★★★★★5.03 weeks ago

We came here at 3pm on a Wednesday afternoon and luckily there was no line. Excellent pizza. I loved their hot boi (most creative pizza i’ve seen in a while) but their regular slice was about on par with other pizza places in the city. Would definitely come back!

Kelvin Lin★★★★★★★★★★3.03 months ago

Pizzas were delicious and what I expected from NY pizza with the nice crust. The plain slice was perfect but the hot slice was a bit greasy/soggy that the dough tore apart a bit when I lifted it. Service was quick since I went for lunch. However, they assumed I wanted a medium size beer when I wanted the small glass. Also, this restaurant has changed since the last time I went. It's been a while. Now, you either order takeout or dine in with waiter service. Back then, you can just order at the counter and eat it inside without waiter service. It is awkward that to dine in a pizza joint that comes with waiter service, though it is also unfeasible to do takeout during the winter, yet they serve the pizza slices on paper plates. Some restaurants should not be waiter service. Feels like they just want to make a few extra dollars making it waiter service so that more people will give tip money. It should be the old format: order standing up, get your slices of pizza, sit at a table without waiter service, finish in 5 minutes and leave. It's so awkward to have this kind of environment at a pizza joint.

Frank Fazzalari★★★★★★★★★★4.0a month ago

Visited Scarr's Pizza while in Manhattan. The atmosphere was classic NYC slice shop — busy and energetic, and the service was good, with a slight wait. When you’re in Manhattan, you better have a food plan, good runners, and an appetite. We popped in for a few slices — the pizza was good, but not quite through-the-roof memorable. Overall, a good experience and worth stopping in if you’re in the area, but not a must-go destination. Saluti.

TechnicaVoX★★★★★★★★★★1.03 weeks ago

Came down from midtown to try a slice and thought it could be much better. Incredibly small slice for $7.50 and pretty tasteless. Also, the garlic knots came out cold and super doughy. For a number 1 of pizza in New York I was very disappointed. I’ll probably try someplace with lower # of reviews with high ratings for a more authentic experience.